Worldline: suspicions over €200 million in cash flow send the stock plunging
Worldline is under pressure again on the Paris stock exchange this Friday, November 20. According to an investigation by the Financial Times, the payments specialist allegedly delayed certain supplier payments and obtained advance payments from its customers to improve its cash flows ahead of several financial publications. A PwC report cited by the British daily puts the effect of certain transactions on 2022 cash flow at €200 million. The group states that its accounts contain no irregularities.
A PwC report calls 2022 cash flow into question
Worldline's cash management practices between 2021 and 2023 are the subject of suspicions. In an investigation published this Friday, November 20, the Financial Times claims that the French company allegedly postponed payments to its suppliers on several occasions and requested early payments from its customers as its results announcements approached.
The British daily relies on internal documents and testimonies gathered from people familiar with the matter. These transactions would have allowed Worldline to report cash flows higher than those that would have been recorded without these payment timing differences.
The investigation notably refers to a report prepared by PwC for Worldline at the end of 2023. According to the conclusions reported by the newspaper, the free cash flow of €520 million announced for 2022 would have been €200 million lower in the absence of certain optimization effects.
The gap represents nearly 38.5% of the published amount. Without these effects, free cash flow would theoretically have been reduced to €320 million, according to the figure reported by the newspaper. This amount constitutes a counterfactual estimate and not an official restatement of the accounts.
A financial indicator nonetheless highlighted in the results
The significance of these revelations is all the greater because Worldline had presented its cash generation as one of the highlights of its 2022 financial year.
In its annual results published on February 21, 2023, the group announced free cash flow of €520 million, up 25.5% from the previous year. The conversion rate of its earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) into cash reached 45.9%, exceeding the target of approximately 45% set for the year.
However, according to the Financial Times, the PwC report also indicated that this conversion rate would have been lower than the levels published in 2021, 2022 and early 2023, on a fully normalized basis.
The issue therefore goes beyond the amount of cash available at the end of the period. It also concerns the group's ability to convert its operating performance into cash, an indicator used to assess its financial position.
The practices described by the British daily are not necessarily illegal. Delaying the payment of a supplier or obtaining an early settlement may fall within ordinary working capital management, provided that contractual obligations are respected.
Their repetition as financial closings approach may, however, alter the perception of a company's cash generation. A payment postponed beyond a closing date temporarily improves the period's liquidity, without eliminating the amount still due.
Worldline denies any irregularity, but the stock falls
Worldline responded in a press release published on November 20, reaffirming the compliance of its financial statements.
The group emphasizes that its accounts are reviewed by the audit committee, approved by the board of directors, certified by the statutory auditors and submitted for shareholder approval. It affirms that they comply with all applicable rules and contain no irregularities.
The company also deplores the repetition of old allegations. It specifies that its board of directors ensures that serious concerns raised about it are examined, particularly within the framework of whistleblowing procedures.
In this press release, however, Worldline does not provide any specific figure in response to the estimate of €200 million attributed to PwC by the Financial Times.
The stock market reaction was abrupt. Around 4 p.m., the share price had lost nearly 15% compared with the previous day's close.
This new decline recalls that of October 25, 2023. Following the downward revision of its annual forecasts, Worldline had then lost 59.24% of its value in a single trading session.